Episode 147: Edgar Wright’s Shaun of the Dead (2004)
Rotten Tomato Score: 92%
92% on Rotten Tomatoes sounds like a sure thing, right? Not when we put Shaun Of The Dead (2004) under our Screams and Streams microscope and realize we’re not even close to aligned on what makes a horror comedy “great.” One of us calls it a top-to-bottom classic, another lands at a solid but stubbornly unimpressed score, and suddenly we’re debating taste, tone, and whether certain jokes are doing the movie any favors.
We start with the basics: Edgar Wright’s breakout style, Simon Pegg and Nick Frost’s chemistry, and the premise of two aimless roommates getting forced into adulthood by a zombie apocalypse. Then we get specific, because that’s where the fun is. We run through our “Sinister Sip” cocktail the Winchester Pint, dig into zombie movie tropes like hiding a bite and “safe places” getting overrun, and trade our favorite one-liners that still hit no matter how many times you’ve watched.
From there, we talk about what dates the film (hello landlines and CRT TVs), what still stands out (the editing, the banter, the subtle horror references), and which moments are genuinely creepy when the comedy drops away. We close with behind-the-scenes trivia and our final watchability scores, which might be the widest gap we’ve had yet.
Sinister Sips
Winchester Pint
From: ScreenSips.com
Recipe:
12 oz dark ale (such as Newcastle Brown)
1 oz dark rum
0.5 oz blackcurrant cordial
2 dashes Angostura bitters
0.25 oz fresh lemon juice
Chill a pint glass in the freezer for at least 10 minutes
Combine dark rum, blackcurrant cordial, bitters, and lemon juice in the bottom of the cold pint glass
Slowly pour the dark ale down the side of the tilted glass to preserve the head
Let settle for 30 seconds until the layers integrate
Serve as-is with no garnish — Ed wouldn't bother
Plot Summary:
The uneventful, aimless lives of a London electronics salesman and his layabout roommate are disrupted by the zombie apocalypse. (Taken from IMDb)
Watchability Scale
Mike loved it and gave it a 10. Chad likes the film and gave it a 9. It wasn’t Sam’s cup of tea and she gave it a 6. We placed the film at 8.5 on the Watchability Scale.
Links
Movie Facts (TV Tropes)